patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Darien Residents Voice Support for $77.2 Million Education Budget

The Board of Education will vote on next year's spending package on Feb. 8.

 

Residents urged the Board of Education to add a guidance counselor at Darien High School, retain instructional aides in the elementary schools, and add foreign language instruction in the elementary schools, at a public hearing Thursday night.

In January, Superintendent Stephen Falcone asked for a $77.2 million spending package for 2011-2012, which would be an 8 percent increase from the current $71.5 million budget. The projected increase would add about $1.9 million in teachers’ salaries; more than $1.2 million in teachers’ health insurance, and nearly $1.1 million in new special education expenses. Additionally, it would add one teacher at Darien High School; one guidance counselor at the high school; 1.25 teachers at Middlesex Middle School; five foreign language teachers across the five elementary schools; one elementary school level social worker; one secondary psychologist; one aide; and two budget control posts, which can be used for special education or for regular education.

Board of Finance members critiqued the spending plan as excessively high at an earlier meeting. In turn, Falcone trimmed his request to about $76.5 million, which would be an increase of 6.9 percent from current spending.

On Thursday, Darien residents who spoke at a public hearing overwhelmingly supported this proposed spending package. Tammy Sload and Laurie Orem, co-chairwomen of the Council of Darien School Parents, compared the Darien school district with its district reference group: New Canaan, Wilton, Weston, Westport, Ridgefield, Redding and Easton.

Asking the board to approve the budget with minimal reductions, Sload characterized special education costs as an unfunded state mandate, as the state imposes requirements but does not allocate enough money to the districts.

“Darien schools have been excellent, but maintaining excellence in any endeavor requires continued investment of time, energy, or in this case money,” Sload said. “We recognize the difficult economic situation all around us, and in Darien. “However, it is time for the town to reassess its commitment to education.”

Orem also compared Darien with its district reference group towns, as well as Connecticut overall. In terms of per pupil expenditures, Darien spends about $1,000 less than its district reference group towns. Of the 169 municipalities in Connecticut, Darien ranks third in its ability to pay for a public education, based on property values and income, she said.

Darien High School guidance counselors each currently work with 220 students, whereas the district reference group towns average 188 apiece. If Darien were to hire another guidance counselor, it would result in each counselor working with 191 students. Toward this end, Orem supported adding another guidance counselor, as well as teaching positions at the high school.

Relative to the number of students per classroom, Darien is slightly higher than the district reference group average.

“We are very grateful for the Board of Education’s commitment to its class size policy, and we hope this continues,” Orem said. “We must point out, however, that our class size policy and our class sizes are larger than our peer towns.”

In a similar vein, Orem distinguished between Darien taxpayers funding a public education versus individual residents who privately donate money to improve educational opportunities in Darien.

“Parents are asked to fund more. In addition, the PTOs in Darien have gone far beyond the usual enrichment programs and field days,” Orem said, citing out-of-town field trips, access to ice rinks, access to tennis courts, and music education. “PTOs have paid for everything from playgrounds and stage floors to common room renovations. This is not happening in other towns.”

Susan Vogel, the Middlesex Middle School budget representative, urged the board to support adding a psychologist, because more students are experiencing traumatic losses in their personal lives.

“At the high school and middle school, there have been a growing number of students in crises,” she said, citing a parent’s death, divorce or loss of a job.

In addition to working with students, a school psychologist works with families to refer them to outside mental health professionals.

Colleen Lyons, the special education budget representative, requested the board leave all current special education staffing positions in place. More special education students are experiencing emotional issues, including crises that require the child be treated by outside mental health care professionals.

“When a student is in crisis, many staff members are involved,” Lyons said. “…This takes our staff members away from their regular duties.”  

Three Darien students have undergone forensic psychiatric evaluations at Yale University this academic year to determine if they pose a threat to themselves or others, she said. “We in Darien are not immune to the ever-increasing challenges,” she said.

Jennifer Montanaro, a co-chairman of the Hindley School PTO, opposed reducing instructional aides, and supported adding a foreign language program in the elementary schools.  

“In the past, the elementary schools have benefitted from many new initiatives, and for that we are very grateful,” she said. “Adopting full-day kindergarten was a big positive.”

Instructional aides perform vital tasks, Montanaro said. From supervising children while the teacher provides individual help to struggling students, monitoring the playground to preventing bullying, to leading instruction when a teacher leaves due to illness during the day, instructional aides are irreplacable.

“The slightest amount of time being cut from instructional aides cannot happen in a class of 25 students in elementary school,” Montanaro said. The instructional aide seamlessly leads the class if a teacher is dealing with a student in crisis.

Two instructional aides supervise 100 students in the cafeteria. “With the increase in food allergies, proper supervision is needed more now than ever,” Montanaro said.

The public hearing gave Darien residents a chance to address the board of education about the spending package, board chairman Kim Westcott said. As such, board members listened, but did not address questions.

The board will vote on setting next year’s budget at its meeting Tuesday, Feb. 8, at its office on the lower level of Town Hall.

Related Topics: School Budget

John Sini

9:16 am on Friday, February 4, 2011

Last night, The Council of Darien School Parents (CDSP) did a extremely effective job of analyzing the BOE's budget over the last several years.

By just reading the headlines, it's quite easy to attack the BOE's preliminary budget increase. However, I encourage all interested parties to get their hands on a copy of CDSP's presentation to see what has happened to the school budget over the last three years.

Outside of the [unfunded] special education spending requirements mandated by the state, its very clear that spending per pupil in the Darien School District has languished, at the detriment to the majority of our student body.

Reply

Tom Valentino

11:40 am on Friday, February 4, 2011

The BOE should offer to mitigate the increase by staying at the Town Hall alongside the new Senior Center (there is plenty of space for both)
and letting the town do something more financially positive for 35 Leroy instead of constructing a government building at the site.

Reply
Comment_arrow

John Boulton

8:51 am on Saturday, February 5, 2011

Gee, that wasn't a politically motivated comment from our friends at the DTC, was it?

Comment_arrow

John Sini

9:52 am on Saturday, February 5, 2011

Mr. Valentino, I would really like to leave politics out of the discussion over the school budget. This discussion should focus on the facts and merits of the BOE's request for funds.

Sure, we can point fingers all day why Darien finds itself facing these tax increases, but from the education budget standpoint, it's increase is primarily due to two factors: Unfunded state mandates for special education and declines in state funding.

I'm sorry that you find yourself at odds with the proposed facilities "shuffle," perhaps next election your party can run three BOS candidates to secure the majority so it can pursue policies that better fits your views. That said, please don't try to tie that discussion to the school budget discussion - it serves no one, including our children, well.

eat

9:21 pm on Friday, February 4, 2011

yes, and partner up with New Canaan and Westport to mitigate costs. Pull the special ed budget out of the regular ed budget, and create efficiencies by joining up with area towns.

Reply

max

10:00 am on Saturday, February 5, 2011

"eat" has an interesting idea. Can anyone with knowledge comment on this?

Reply
Comment_arrow

eat

10:42 am on Saturday, February 5, 2011

max -- they do this in parts of CA (with similar demographics here)...our school district may be reluctant to change as this is such a sensitive area (I know b/c I have typical and special need child)...but we could start of small and get together with a couple of other districts and agree to set the rates for consultants and work towards other efficiences as the concept gains more acceptance. We need to think outside of the box about how to control or at least manage our special education costs better...and by no means is this a dig at our programs -- they are top notch, it's the costs that are out of control due to state and federal mandates.

ken danyo

10:17 am on Saturday, February 5, 2011

if the dtc has some 'financially positive' ideas, why not state them?
i read for a long time, how the democrats bizarrely said ' affordable housing at the site would be the only option that would not cost the town money.' how can mr. valentino sequeway 'financially positive-' from a perspective of education costs ?
Is he , like the democratic selectmen, unaware that more kids in school= equals significant more costs?
If you want to talk , mr valentino about that site, you'd do yourself a favor by not doing it in the midst of a discussion on the costs of education.
if they want to play dumb, then they are doing an excellent job.

Reply

John Boulton

10:49 am on Saturday, February 5, 2011

Max,
I could spend hours discussing this, but a few points (and I'll address only the budget issues, not the qualitative educational merits, in case any parents get mad at my comments):
- The State and Feds gave the Special Ed (SPED) parents a lot of leverage; they can effectively require districts to teach their special needs student in the regular classroom of the neighborhood school ("inclusion model"). Not only is the inclusion model a big driver behind SPED budget increases (the BOE has had to hire countless # of aides, nurses, and teachers over the years to address in-classroom needs, often after the budget is approved), but I suspect the SPED parents could likely stop a regionalization process from being truly effective.
- Darien already uses other districts' SPED programs when it's the most reasonable way to address a child's needs. But, SPED transportation is VERY expensive (e.g., by law, an aide must be on the bus along with a driver; point-to-point routes mean no economies of scale), and is one reason why Darien tries to address things in-house.
- Be VERY careful with the idea of regionalizing our schools; it is a slippery slope. At the end of the day, someone has to be in charge (how do we resolve differences with NC or Westport over programs?), and a regional scheme would mean diluted local control. I won't support it; I already think the Legislature micro-manages our schools to an unacceptable level as it is.

Reply
Comment_arrow

eat

11:08 am on Saturday, February 5, 2011

A regional scheme -- yes, absolutely it means diluting local control. But we are bound by state and federal mandates -- so how much are we in control anyway when it comes to special education? This a problem for our school district that will not go away. Keeping an open mind to other ideas and looking at other models will only help us in the future. My point is that we need to look at how other school districts are doing this in these tough times and look for any ways to create efficiencies when it comes to special education, because budget constraints are starting to affect the educational quality of regular education students. If our SAT and CMT scores start to lag other area school districts in the next few years, then maybe something will be done. Sooner might be better.

John Sini

10:54 am on Saturday, February 5, 2011

I also understand lawsuits brought against the district are also quite costly because under state law, the district is essentially held culpable, until it can prove itself "innocent."

Reply
Comment_arrow

eat

11:30 am on Saturday, February 5, 2011

right, John. And Darien has higher lawsuit costs related to special edcuation than New Canaan. Can we learn from them?

Comment_arrow

Debra Ritchie

3:48 pm on Saturday, February 5, 2011

Connecticut is one of only a few states that put the burden on the school district rather than the parent. That needs to change, but there is little hope for that. Special Education is a growing cost to the town and unless we find a way to control the costs better, the rest of education spending will continue to be negatively impacted. While all the comments made by CDSP made sense, there were no solutions proposed. Let's stop talking about what we want and how spending more money is the solution, and think outside the box about how we can get our children what they really need by managing the system better.

John Sini

11:52 am on Saturday, February 5, 2011

Eat, perhaps.... But we may just have more litigious parents herein Darien, so that is a good question, but might be tough to answer.

Reply

John Boulton

11:55 am on Saturday, February 5, 2011

eat, I'm not necessarily disagreeing (I told the RTM for years that Special Ed vs Regular Ed was a train wreck in the making), but wouldn't sell the BOE short on their efforts to address these issues. And, I would be careful to compare districts too closely. SPED is a bottom-up aggregation of individual IEP costs, so individual cases can impact costs disproportionately.

Reply
Comment_arrow

eat

1:47 pm on Saturday, February 5, 2011

John -- to clarify, I am not advocating centralizing regular education, and not advocating making regionalized centers for special education... just we should look at non-fulltime special education resources in the classroom that perhaps can be shared among districts such as consultants, therapists and the like, and potentially benefitting to things such as fixed pay rates among agreed upon school districts to help lower costs across the board. We could also look at efficiencies among school districts in the manner in which IEPs are developed and managed, to avoid litigious outcomes.

Comment_arrow

Debra Ritchie

3:54 pm on Saturday, February 5, 2011

We should not fear litigation, but we absolutely need a system that is better organized and managed. Shouldn't there be someone on the BOE who oversees SPED and shouldn't the BOE be hearing from SPED more than once or twice each year?

Comment_arrow

John Boulton

3:55 pm on Saturday, February 5, 2011

eat, thanks. We could go on all day! (...let's not!)
I hear your points, I just wouldn't sell the BOE short on their efforts.

John Boulton

12:00 pm on Saturday, February 5, 2011

eat, interesting that NC is giving out that kind of data; getting SPED budget data out of them used to be impossible. Again, I would be careful to jump to conclusions since you don't know the nature of the litigation (and most SPED cases are due process cases, not lawsuits per se).

Reply
Comment_arrow

eat

12:19 pm on Saturday, February 5, 2011

It's common knowledge among parents of special education students between the two school districts because we interact with eachother and have the contacts. Of course, we don't know the specifics of the due process cases, all we know is that there is a lot more of them going on in Darien than in NC -- over past couple of years. At some point it becomes a pattern, and legal costs takes away $$ that should be put in other areas, such as reducing class size,adding foreign language, aides, etc -- for the regular education population in Darien. We can not live in a bubble and need to look at how other school districts are mitigating these costs and see if it is feasible to partner up and/or at the very least learn from them. It's called best practices. If we throw our hands up, and say -- there is nothing we can do because it is what it is/ we don't want to share ideas/we don't want to lose local control -- then we are are doing a huge disservice to our community and face the repurcussions down the road . Other areas of the country have been able to see the "big picture," let's hope we can too.

John Sini

12:34 pm on Saturday, February 5, 2011

Other areas of the country don't put the burden of proof on the school districts either. I believe Connecticut is only one of two states that has this law.

Reply
Comment_arrow

eat

12:52 pm on Saturday, February 5, 2011

That's a great point. Even more reason to take a step back and figure out how we can better manage our challenges facing our school district: because it costs us more than other areas of the country when conflict arises....

max

2:12 pm on Sunday, February 6, 2011

It sounds like bad law. Can't bad laws be fixed?

Reply

Leave a comment