Are organic pesticides worth the additional cost? (YES!)

Are organic pesticides worth the additional cost? (YES!)

Last week I wrote about Autumn being the single most important time of year to spray for ticks. In that blog I promised I'd address this week what the difference is between traditional (laboratory created) chemical pesticides versus organic.

Most people buy milk and I'm going to use that as my baseline. One gallon of Horizon Organic Whole milk this week at Target is selling for $6.79. One gallon of Market Pantry (Target's brand) Whole Milk-not organic-is selling for $2.49. Mathematically that is a difference of 2.72 times higher for the organic milk than traditional milk. I'm not a diary expert nor do I claim to be one, but I wanted to begin this blog by showing something as simple as milk has a value of 272% more than traditional milk.

Why organic pesticides-tick sprays in particular-over traditional sprays?

The technical material which has been available to all pesticide applicators for the past decade for residential tick sprays is called a Bifrenthrin-a pyrethroid insecticide. This is what commercial applicators and companies have used to kill ticks on your property the non-organic way for over a decade, and this is certainly one way. Is it effective and does it do the job? Absolutely! Is it cost effective? Absolutely! What else does it do though? It leaves an unpleasant odor, causes you and your pets to stay off your lawn for 24 hours (hence the little yellow lawn signs when the applicator leaves) and leaves no where for Fido to "go" or the kids to play. Bifenthrin is highly toxic to fish and small aquatic organisms. It's also very highly toxic to bees.

And what about what it can do to Fido? According to the National Pesticide Institute "Exposed pets may experience single-episode vomiting or diarrhea, reduced activity, twitching of the ear, paw flicking and increased drooling. Other signs can include hyperactivity followed by incoordination with diarrhea, depression, and dilated pupils. Some veterinarians have reported additional signs such as chewing, head bobbing, partial paralysis, and tremors." It's no wonder that people with dogs and roaming pets likes horses demand organic sprays.

Bifenthrin uses insecticides to kill. Further, with only 10 years of laboratory results on file, how do we know that it isn't affecting people long term? What guarantee is there in 15 years that we won't find out that memories and health of human hasn't been compromised? There is none. The U.S. EPA classifies Bifenthrin as a possible human carcinogen. 

If you're not hiring a commercial applicator for your tick problem (and if you live in Connecticut you do have one) then you are hitting the big box stores to buy Sevin. Sevin is a carbonate class of pesticides; in lay mans terms it is toxic to humans, pets and bugs. It is cheap and widely used to control insects in and around the home. Cats are the household pet most sensitive to Sevin followed by dogs when tested by the EPA.

Conversely, organic alternatives are available but cost often deters people. The difference on a one acre property industry wide on a spray is about $100. That is less than 40% increase whereas milk sees a 272% increase. Organic spray leaves a pleasant cedar smell, has no harmful residue that stick to your pets and family and the yard can be used immediately.

The average one acre lot will use 100 gallon of material whether it is organic or traditional. Given the choice of spraying 100 gallons of organic material versus 100 gallon of traditional technical material-what do you choose? And what is your doctor and nutritionist choosing? Where do the majority of customers who contact organic IPM businesses come from? The referrals come in from doctors, mothers groups for autistic children, veterinarians and educated homeowners who are health and environmentally conscious.

Why commercial sprayer instead of a backpack sprayer for the tick applcaition?

Backpack sprayers hold 5 gallons only and rely on a more concentrated amount therefore the greater the chances of coming into contact with a concentrated pesticide. Backpacks also do not offer the volume or pressure required to disrupt and penetrate heavy leaf litter and under shrubs where ticks hide. Ticks prefer shade and moist areas, 30 feet into the woods is where a commercial sprayer can penetrate. This is what is creating the buffer between you and the ticks. Commercial applicators are mixing between 100 to 1000 gallons of material at a time, under supervised and licensed conditions.

Cost is always a factor when deciding on home services but always shop apples to apples. This puts the myths to bed about the cost of organic sprays and gives you food for thought about what you allow yourself, your children and your pets to come into contact with. 

Stacy Skoldberg is managing partner of GreenSprays an IPM company dedicated to organic and natural solutions. In her free time she enjoys gardening and playing with her twins. Stacy can be reached at: 203-916-3666 orstacy@greensprays.com and can be followed on FB: GreenSprays or Twitter: @ greenspraysllc.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Norah G Fon November 02, 2012 at 07:29 PM
Green Alternative Pesticides are not only STUNNINGLY EXPENSIVE, they DO NOT WORK ! They are BOGUS AND DISMAL FAILURES. It is IMPOSSIBLE for home-owners or professionals to keep their properties beautiful by using so-called Green Alternative Pesticides. There are NO viable, efficacious, economical, or low-risk alternatives to replace conventional pest control products. In many cases, Green Alternative Pesticides are questionably HIGHER IN TOXICITY, and pose HIGHER ENVIRONMENTAL RISKS. A well-maintained conventional lawn and landscape can ONLY BE ACHIEVED WITH CONVENTIONAL pest control products and fertilizers. Fortunately, CONVENTIONAL pest control products are SAFE, EFFECTIVE, ECONOMICAL, and LOW-RISK. http://wp.me/P1jq40-24g WILLIAM H. GATHERCOLE AND NORAH G http://pesticidetruths.com/
Stacy from GreenSprays November 04, 2012 at 01:21 AM
@ Norah, did you read the full article? I ask because you would see that the cost is not as you shout in all capitals "stunningly expensive" they are 40% more. You are speaking of what people market as "green alternatives" and again, this article addresses ORGANIC products which are in fact by USDA certification not toxic at all. It is confusing where the above rant is coming from.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »